The contents of this blog are a compendium of multiple media reports and include my personal opinion, where indicated.
Here we go again. We have all seen this movie before. We didn’t like it the previous times, and we like it even less now. Welcome to the world of government shutdowns.
This time House and Senate Democrats, led by Chuck Schumer, Hakeem Jeffries, and a host of other lefties are blocking funding for the Department of Homeland Security, arguing that reforms are necessary to protect citizens. Republicans generally oppose these reforms and denote that, thanks to the BBB, DHS already has sufficient funding to operate for years whereas a shutdown could affect other agencies, such as the Secret Service, Coast Guard, FEMA, and TSA.
What are the chief causes of this shutdown? What are the Dems’ objectives? Why deprive thousands of hard-working Americans of their paychecks and the rest of us of vital services? I’m glad you asked. Read on.
In my opinion this shutdown has an immediate cause and various underlying causes. The immediate cause is the disagreement regarding ICE’s treatment of the untold millions of illegal aliens that poured into the country during the Biden Administration. I have posted several blogs discussing this issue, in detail, and there is no need to repeat it all here. Simply put, the Dems want to give illegals sanctuary (even those who have continued to commit felonious crimes on American citizens) and otherwise bestow upon them all the rights of citizens (or sometimes, even better), most significantly, the right to vote. The Repubs want to locate, detain, and deport them, especially those who have continued to commit crimes. Dems have focused their ire on DHS and ICE and have continually tried to impede them in the lawful performance of their duties.
The spate of violence that the Dems fomented recently in Minneapolis is the latest example. I believe that the Dems wanted to foment violence, and thy succeeeded.
So, what are the underlying issues that have led Shumer and the other far-lefties in the House and Senate to cause the current shutdown? What is their objective?
As I indicated, simply put, they want to reform and restrict the authority of DHS and ICE. Their demands include, among other things, mandating that ICE agents (1) obtain judicial warrants before entering private homes or property, (2) identify themselves, remove masks during operations, and use body-worn cameras, (3) comply with stricter, enforceable codes of conduct to prevent excessive force, (4) cease operations at “sensitive locations” such as schools, hospitals, and churches, (5) verify an individual’s citizenship status before detaining them, (6) wear body cameras, (7) identify themselves, and (8) restrict the use of force.
Furthermore, they continue to advocate for full healthcare benefits for illegals, (which the BBB omitted), maintain sanctuary cities and states, and protect the illegals there. Of course, we have the old standby mantra, oppose anything President Trump does, says, or supports. Read on for details.
Let’s be clear and succinct. As I have discussed in previous blogs, in Minneapolis and elsewhere ICE personnel have been engaged in activities that are mandated by Federal law, which authorizes and requires them to ferret out, detain, and deport illegals. They are all criminals just by virtue of having entered the country illegally. Cities and states that provide sanctuary to illegal aliens are violating Federal law. Anyone who impedes ICE personnel from accomplishing the above is aiding and abetting contraventions of Federal law. That includes Governor Walz, Mayor Frey, and the protesters/demonstrators. They can stand by and hold signs, but speeches or actions that incite violence are illegal. All of the above crossed the line. The killings of Hand and Pretti were tragic, but they were a direct result of the aforementioned illegalities.
This is actually a partial shutdown. Some 95% of the government is already funded. The focal point is DHS, but other agencies such as the TSA, FEMA and the Secret Service have been dragged into it. For now, most of the employees of these agencies are continuing to work with their pay being deferred. Nevertheless, we can anticipate travel disruptions, and we better pray that there are no natural disasters requiring assistance from FEMA.
Ironically, ICE and other Customs and Border Protection agencies, the main targets of the shutdown, have billions of dollars in funding on hand courtesy of the BBB. On the other hand, FEMA and the Transportation Security Administration, face more immediate impacts. So, it would appear that the Dems will be causing inconveniences and disruptions for people for no discernable benefit.
FEMA has reported that its disaster relief fund is currently down to $9.6 billion from roughly $30 billion in December. So far disruptions of air travel have been relatively inconsequential. However, as we learned in past shutdowns they tend to build over time, so sooner or later they will occur. Some of you may recall that about a month into last year’s record-breaking shutdown the TSA was forced to close two checkpoints at Philadelphia International Airport temporarily and directed all commercial airlines to reduce their domestic flight schedules. However, some observers such as John Rose, the chief risk officer for Altour, a global travel management company, are concerned that this time issues could start to “pop up” sooner. In addition, weather is always a complicating factor and there are two potentially historic blizzards on the horizon.
The impact of the shutdown on people and the finger-pointing have commenced and will intensify as time goes on. Today, DHS Secretary Kristi Noem announced DHS has suspended the TSA PreCheck and Global Entry airport security programs, which expedite airport check-in for the many travelers who are members of the programs. Right on cue, critics are complaining that DHS is intentionally “kneecapping” these programs and “ruining [people’s] travel [plans] on purpose.” Of course, that claim is disingenuous since one of the main objectives of the shutdown was to curtail the DHS’ operations. Noem replied to critics that this is an example that “shutdowns have serious real world consequences.”
The tragedy is that the average citizen will be impacted most of all. Many federal employees will be deprived of their livelihood and struggle to provide for their families. Travel will be disrupted. Victims of natural disasters could have the federal assistance they need urgently delayed.
Conclusion
These shutdowns have become routine and tiresome and ultimately don’t accomplish much at all. All the inconveniences, disruptions and pain are felt by the average citizen while the perpetrators, chiefly members of Congress, will not feel the effects in the least. They will continue to bloviate and attack each other. They will continue to get paid. (Why)?
Here’s a novel concept for our congressmen to consider. For the benefit of your constituents why not negotiate and reach a bilateral agreement. DHS has already agreed to implement some of the reforms. Reasonable people can come to an agreement on the remainder. A shutdown is NOT necessary.
Ultimately, as always, there will be an agreement that will not change much. Each side will blame the other. The same underlying issues will persist and recur again and again. This is your government at work.