“DECOY DAN”

As always, the contents of this blog constitute a compendium of information from multiple media sources supplemented by my personal opinion, where indicated.

The current Alaska Senate race is not the first election to be marred by irregularities, and it won’t be the last. The history of US elections is replete with questionable voting tactics, shenanigans, double-dealing, and sundry “dirty tricks,” some of which had a decisive impact not only on the election, itself, but also on the country’s history.. This was especially true back in the days of the power brokers and the “smoke-filled rooms when questionable deals could easily evade public scrutiny. Focusing on just presidential elections there have been several, but due to time and space limitations I will only discuss three.

1. 1824

This election was a wide open contest with four contenders. Andrew Jackson, the popular hero of the War of 1812, won the popular vote and also garnered the most electoral votes – 99.; Secretary of State John Quincy Adams, the son of former president John Adams, won 84; Treasury Secretary William Crawford won 41; and Speaker of the House Henry Clay captured 37. As no candidate had earned a majority of electoral votes, the election was to be decided by the House of Representatives among the top three contestants. After a month of back-room negotiations, Adams and Clay struck a quid pro quo. Esssentially, Clay threw his support to Adams, which put him over the top. In return following his inauguration Adams appointed Clay as his Secretary of State. Jackson was irate and denounced it as a “corrupt bargain.” Most historians believe it was at least shady, but the decision stood, although Jackson got his revenge in 1828.

2. 1860

This election was the last one before the Civil War. It was not only contentious and controversial but also it turned out to be the last straw before seven pro-slavery southern states seceded from the union. The Dems nominated Senator Stephen Douglas. The southern branch of the Party strenuously objected to that choice, split off and nominated Vice President John Breckenridge. Tennessee Senator. John Bell was the candidate of the new Constitutional Union Party. The fledgling Republican Party, which had only been formed in 1854, nominated Abraham Lincoln. Due to his strong opposition to slavery Lincoln wasn’t on the ballot in most Southern states. The four candidates split the electoral votes to the extent that Linclon won despite only receiving 40% of the popular vote. The Civil War commenced shortly thereafter.

3. 1876

In my opinion, this one”takes the cake.” On Election Day Dem NY Governor Samuel Tilden won the popular vote by 250,000 over Repub Rutherford B. Hayes and garnered 19 more electoral votes. with 20 votes undecided. In my view, clearly he was the choice of the electorate.. Unfortunately, he was still one electoral vote short of the required majority of 185. The contests in Florida, Louisiana and South Carolina, which totaled 20 votes, had not been were not fully counted, were still too close to call, and highly controversial. Each party was accusing the other of fraud. Moreover, one elector in Oregon was declared ineligible and replaced. The election seemed to be hopelessly deadlocked with neither side willing to negotiate. A constitutional crisis loomed. Some feared another Civil War could erupt.

Finally, in an unprecedented decision Congress established a 15-member commission of senators, congressmen and Supreme Court justices (including seven Republicans, seven Democrats and one independent) to decide the election. Eventually, Hayes was awarded all 21 contested votes, which put him over the top. However, the Dems were not done. They threatened to filibuster and block the official vote counting. Finally, in February 1877 a controversial compromise was reached. The Dems agreed to accept Hayes as the victor provided that he remove all federal troops from the South, whose presence had been a big benefit to African Americans This historical action consolidated Dem control of the former slave states and led to decades of discrimination, pain and suffering among African American domiciled in the South.

As I write this the tale of “Decoy Dan” is ongoing. He was recruited to run because he shared the same first and last name with the Repub incumbent, Dan Sullivan. The hope was that enough voters would confuse the two and vote for the decoy instead of the encumbent to swing the election to Dem candidate Mary Petola. As I write this the vote count is 98% complete. Petola is leading the encumbent Sullivan 49.98% to 45.93% Decoy Dan with 1.65% has had an impact but not a decisive one. Although Petola is ahead she is short of the 50% needed to avoid a runoff.

Meanwhile, DD is nowhere to be found. He was last seen in public on October 26. Rumor has it he fled to Colorado where some of his relatives reside. The authorities are looking for him to question him with respect to the matter. A critical question is what role did Petola and her campaign play in the scheme. Furthermore, DD, himself, may have some culpability.

CONCLUSION

We can debate whether the tale of “Decoy Dan” was worse than the above examples or not but at least we have to give the Dems points for originality. Whoever, thought up this scheme deserves a “gold star” for originality, for “thinking outside the box,” and plain old chutzpah.

Questions p ersist. Are the Dems about to “steal” a Senate seat? What part did Dem candidate Mary Petola or her campaign play? Was it legal or not? If not, what laws did it violate? Did it violate election laws? Does it meet the definition of a “conspiracy” against voters? Did the parties violate any federal laws such as committing wire fraud?

Most importantly, how, if at all, did DD’s votes affect the validity of the election? I suspect the lawyers will be fighting over this for some time.

Leave a Reply